All articles
Development30 Jul 20261 min read

Shopify theme or headless? How to choose

Headless can be brilliant, but it isn't always the upgrade it sounds like. Four questions help you pick the right build for your brand.

In this article

“Headless” means building your own storefront and running Shopify behind it for products, carts and checkout. It gives you complete control. It also gives you more to build and maintain.

What a theme gives you

Online Store 2.0 themes are built from sections your team can edit, reorder and reuse without a developer. Most Shopify apps are designed to work with them. A well-built custom theme can be very fast, and it’s the quickest and most affordable way to launch.

What headless gives you

With Shopify’s Hydrogen framework hosted on Oxygen, or a framework such as Next.js, every part of the front end is yours. You can build rich, story-led content, combine several brands or content sources, and create interactions a theme can’t.

The trade-offs are real:

  • Higher build cost and longer timelines.
  • Apps that add features to themes often won’t work, so some need rebuilding.
  • Most changes need a developer, so running costs are higher.

Four questions to ask

  1. Can a custom theme do 90% of what we need? If so, start there.
  2. Does our content go beyond products, collections and a blog?
  3. Do we have budget for ongoing development, not just the build?
  4. Is our current site slow because of the theme, or because of apps and images?

The middle ground

Many brands get what they want from a custom theme with bespoke sections, plus Shopify Functions and checkout extensions for custom discounts and checkout features. It also leaves a clear path to headless later if you need it.

Talk to us about your project

Get Finch Notes by email.

One practical article a month on growing a Shopify store. Unsubscribe any time.

Work with us

Ready for your next stage of growth?

Tell us where you want to take your brand. Our team will come back within one working day with next steps.

Your privacy

We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to understand how it's used and to measure our marketing. Read our cookie policy.

↑↓ to moveEnter to openEsc to closeFuzzy search across every page

Region

We work with clients across the UK and beyond. Prices are in pounds (GBP) and exclude VAT. The site is in English (UK).